I just read this really interesting and slightly controversial article online
It is taken from From September 14, 2008
A Dublin- based study carried out by Utah University in America has questioned the effectiveness of IVF
Natural fertility treatment is more effective than in-vitro fertilisation (IVF), according to new research by the University of Utah in America.
It found that one in four of the 1,100 couples treated with natural methods in a clinic in Galway had successful pregnancies using natural procreative technology treatment (NPT). This compares with the most recent European success rates of 18.4% for IVF.
The research, published last week in the Journal of the American Board of Family Medicine, has been disputed by Tony Walsh, director of the Sims Fertility Clinic in Dundrum, Dublin. He claimed the study was not scientifically sound and did not constitute proof that NPT gives comparable live birthrates to IVF. The clinic has sent a letter to the journal outlining its argument.
But the study is being hailed as a landmark paper by supporters of NPT, as it is the first research into the effectiveness of the method to be published in a peerreviewed medical journal. It also found that the number of multiple births resulting from NPT was significantly lower than using artificial methods, with only 4.6% of women becoming pregnant with more than one child.
This compares with multiple birth rates of 34% recorded in a recent American study of couples undergoing assisted reproductive technology (ART).
Joseph Stanford from the University of Utah in Salt Lake City, the main author, said that he hoped the research would help overcome the current information deficit surrounding NPT.
Many GPs and obstetricians are not aware of NPT because of a lack of published studies, he said. Now physicians can inform themselves of this treatment approach and hopefully recommend it to their patients.
Read the rest of the article here http://www.timesonline.co.uk
I have not heard of NPT before so I am now going to look it up and post what I find. If anyone knows more please feel free to comment.